Pinot Noir is the best wine for filet mignon. Tenderloin is the leanest steak, with little fat to soften young Cabernet's tannin, so a silky, medium-bodied red usually suits it better; a rich sauce can change that. Domaine de la Rivière, a Russian River Valley family estate, pours its 2022 Red Barn Block Pinot Noir (96 points) and 2022 Two Forces Pinot Noir (98 points), both from The Tasting Panel.
Below: the bottles we'd open with a filet, why Pinot Noir works with a lean steak, when Cabernet Sauvignon is the better call, a sauce-by-sauce pairing chart, white wine with steak, surf and turf, beef Wellington and chateaubriand, how to serve red wine with steak, and what to pour for Christmas Eve, New Year's or an anniversary.
Which wines do we pour with filet mignon?
For filet mignon, Domaine de la Rivière opens Pinot Noir first: a structured, savory one for a filet with a red wine or mushroom sauce, a fuller, darker one for a plain seared steak, and its oldest-vine Pinot for a special occasion. For béarnaise or a lobster tail on the side, it pours an old-vine Chardonnay.
In magnum
A magnum holds two bottles, about ten glasses, which is the right amount for a chateaubriand or a whole roasted tenderloin for six. The wine also ages more slowly in the larger bottle. We make very few.
Shop the Set
Curated collections
What wine goes with filet mignon?
A medium-bodied red with soft tannin and fresh acidity: Pinot Noir first, then Merlot or a Cabernet Sauvignon with some bottle age. Filet mignon is cut from the tenderloin, a muscle that does little work, so it is very tender, mild in flavor and low in fat. It needs a wine with finesse more than force.
The tenderloin runs along the spine beneath the ribs, and filet mignon (French for "dainty fillet") is the round steak cut from it, usually 1.5 to 2 inches thick and 6 to 8 ounces. With so little marbling, most of the flavor on the plate comes from the seared crust, the butter baste and the sauce. Match the wine to the weight of the whole plate, not to the word "steak".
- Soft tannin. Tannin is the drying grip in red wine. It binds to fat and protein, which is why it feels smoother next to a marbled ribeye. Lean filet gives it less to bind to, so a very tannic wine can taste harsh.
- Fresh acidity. A butter baste, béarnaise or a cream sauce needs acidity to cut through it and refresh the palate between bites.
- Medium body. A heavy, high-alcohol red can bury a mild cut; a very light red disappears beside a seared crust.
- Savory notes. Earth, mushroom and spice in the wine echo the browned crust and any mushroom or pan sauce.
- Doneness matters a little. A rare or medium-rare filet is juicier and handles more structure; cooked past medium, the meat is drier and a softer, fruitier red works better.
Why does Pinot Noir work with filet mignon?
Pinot Noir has some of the softest tannin of any red grape, bright acidity and a medium body, which matches a lean, tender steak instead of overpowering it. Its acidity cuts the butter baste, and its earthy, savory notes echo the seared crust and mushrooms. A cool-climate Pinot keeps the freshness that makes this work.
The match is about proportion. A filet's texture is fine and its flavor delicate, and a Pinot Noir's tannin is fine-grained rather than coarse, so neither crowds the other. Where Cabernet relies on fat to tame it, Pinot Noir is already supple; where the steak is basted in butter with garlic and thyme, the wine's acidity does the job a squeeze of lemon would.
A light, simple Pinot can taste thin beside a dark crust, so look for a structured, savory style with dark fruit, the kind the fog-cooled Russian River Valley makes. Domaine de la Rivière's 2022 Red Barn Block Pinot Noir, from the block beside the estate's old red barn, is that style: black cherry, clove, dried rose and cedar, structured and savory. It earned 96 points from The Tasting Panel, 95 points and an Editor's Choice from Wine Enthusiast, and a Double Gold at the San Francisco Chronicle. The 2022 Two Forces Pinot Noir, blended from estate Vineyard eleven and El Diablo Vineyard fruit, is fuller and darker, with black cherry, rose petal and baking spice over fine-grained tannin; it scored 98 points from The Tasting Panel.
Is Cabernet Sauvignon good with filet mignon?
Yes, in the right setting. Cabernet Sauvignon is the classic steak wine because its firm tannin cuts through fat, which makes it ideal for ribeye and strip. With a plain filet, a young, tannic Cabernet can overpower the meat. With a red wine reduction, peppercorn or blue cheese sauce, or with an older bottle whose tannin has softened, it works well.
Plenty of people prefer Cabernet with filet, and it is a steakhouse classic. The fair version of the rule: the leaner the steak and the simpler the preparation, the softer the red should be. A sauce adds the richness the cut lacks, and ten or more years in bottle rounds out Cabernet's tannin. Merlot, with similar dark fruit and gentler tannin, sits between the two. The table below applies the same logic to other cuts, for anyone asking what wine goes with steak in general.
| Steak | What it's like | Wine that suits it |
|---|---|---|
| Filet mignon (tenderloin) | Leanest and most tender; mild flavor | Pinot Noir, Merlot, an older Cabernet |
| Ribeye | Heavily marbled, rich, beefy | Young Cabernet, Syrah, Malbec, Zinfandel |
| New York strip | Firm, beefy, a fat cap along one side | Cabernet, Merlot, Syrah, a structured Pinot Noir |
| Porterhouse or T-bone | Strip on one side, tenderloin on the other | Cabernet, or a fuller Pinot Noir to cover both |
| Top sirloin | Leaner, beefy, good value | Merlot, Malbec, Pinot Noir |
| Flank or skirt | Lean, grilled hot, often marinated | Malbec, Zinfandel, a fruit-forward Pinot Noir |
| Prime rib | Marbled rib roast, served with jus | Cabernet; Pinot Noir with an herb crust |
What wine goes with filet mignon with each sauce?
Pair the wine to the sauce, because it carries more flavor than the meat. Butter, béarnaise and mushroom sauces suit Pinot Noir or a full Chardonnay. Red wine reductions and bordelaise suit a fuller red. Peppercorn wants spice in the wine, and blue cheese wants the most structure on the table.
| Filet with… | Red to pour | White or Rosé | Why |
|---|---|---|---|
| Béarnaise | A lighter, bright Pinot Noir | Full-bodied Chardonnay | Egg yolk, butter and tarragon want acidity; the white is an even match. |
| Butter, garlic and thyme baste | Pinot Noir | Chardonnay | Acidity cuts the butter; earthy notes meet the crust. |
| Red wine reduction | A structured Pinot Noir, Merlot or Cabernet | — | Concentrated red wine and stock call for a red with the same depth. |
| Bordelaise | Merlot, a Bordeaux blend, or a structured Pinot Noir | — | Red wine, shallot and bone marrow add body and savoriness. |
| Peppercorn (au poivre) | Syrah, or a Pinot Noir with baking spice | — | Cracked pepper and cream suit a red with its own spice. |
| Mushroom sauce | Pinot Noir | Chardonnay | Pinot Noir's earthy, forest-floor notes mirror the mushrooms. |
| Blue cheese crust or butter | Cabernet, Syrah, or the most structured Pinot | — | Salty, pungent cheese needs a bigger red. |
| Chimichurri | A bright, fruit-forward Pinot Noir | Dry Rosé | Herbs, garlic and vinegar want freshness, not tannin. |
| Horseradish cream | A fruit-forward Pinot Noir | Chardonnay or dry Rosé | Sharp heat makes tannin taste bitter; fruit softens it. |
| Bacon-wrapped | A fuller Pinot Noir | Dry Rosé | Smoke, salt and fat suit a red with dark fruit and spice. |
From Domaine de la Rivière's cellar, that comes out simply. Red wine reduction, bordelaise, mushroom and blue cheese go to the 2022 Red Barn Block Pinot Noir, the most structured and savory bottle. A plain seared filet, peppercorn and bacon-wrapped go to the 2022 Two Forces, which has the baking spice and dark fruit. Béarnaise and the butter baste go to the 2021 Ritchie Vineyard Chardonnay. Chimichurri and horseradish suit a cold glass of Shoshana Rosé of Pinot Noir, which is dry and whole-cluster pressed from estate Pinot Noir.
Can you drink white wine with filet mignon?
Yes. A full-bodied Chardonnay with moderate oak suits filet mignon better than most people expect, because the cut is lean and mild and is often served with butter or béarnaise. Choose a white with real weight and acidity. A light, crisp white such as Pinot Grigio is too delicate for a seared steak.
The red-with-meat rule is really about weight and fat. A filet is lighter than its reputation, and a barrel-fermented Chardonnay can be as substantial as a medium-bodied red. Old-vine fruit adds concentration without extra oak; a heavily oaked, buttery style tastes flat next to a butter baste.
The bottle we'd choose is the 2021 Ritchie Vineyard Chardonnay, from Old Wente vines planted at Ritchie Vineyard in 1972 and farmed by Kent Ritchie. Robb Report named it one of the Top 50 California Chardonnays of the Century; it also won Double Gold at the San Francisco Chronicle and scored 93 points from Owen Bargreen, Jeb Dunnuck and Ken's Wine Guide. It is dense and mineral, which is what a filet with béarnaise needs. White wine is also the easiest answer when half the table is eating fish or lobster.
What wine goes with surf and turf?
Chardonnay is the safest single wine for surf and turf, because a full-bodied one suits both lobster with drawn butter and a lean filet. Pinot Noir works when the steak is the focus or the seafood is grilled shrimp or seared scallops. A dry Rosé of Pinot Noir sits between them and suits both halves of the plate.
| Surf and turf | Pour | Why |
|---|---|---|
| Filet and lobster tail, drawn butter | Full-bodied Chardonnay | Matches the butter and the sweetness of lobster without overpowering the beef. |
| Filet and seared scallops | Chardonnay or a lighter Pinot Noir | Scallops are rich and sweet; both have the acidity for them. |
| Filet and grilled shrimp | Pinot Noir or dry Rosé | Char and garlic suit a red with soft tannin. |
| Two bottles open | Chardonnay and Pinot Noir | Each guest pours toward the half of the plate they care about. |
Tannic reds are the one style to avoid here: tannin makes lobster and shellfish taste metallic. If you open one bottle, make it the Chardonnay; if you open two, the 2021 Ritchie for the lobster and a Pinot Noir for the filet covers everyone. The brighter 2021 Flora Marie Vineyard Chardonnay, 94 points from Wine Enthusiast and the Cristaldi Report, suits shrimp.
What wine goes with beef Wellington and chateaubriand?
Pinot Noir suits both. Beef Wellington is tenderloin coated in mushroom duxelles, often wrapped in prosciutto, and baked in puff pastry, and Pinot Noir's earthy notes echo the mushrooms. Chateaubriand is the thick center cut of the tenderloin, roasted for two or more and traditionally served with béarnaise, so Pinot Noir or a full Chardonnay fits.
Both are filet mignon at a larger scale: a lean cut that needs soft tannin, plus a rich element that needs acidity. With a red wine reduction poured over either, move up to a more structured red, such as the Red Barn Block or a Cabernet with some age. For a formal Wellington on Christmas Day, the 2021 Heritage Block Pinot Noir, from the estate's oldest plantings, is the bottle we'd decant; it scored 95 points from the Cristaldi Report and placed No. 66 on its Top 100 Wines of 2025. The Christmas dinner guide covers Wellington alongside prime rib, ham and duck.
Wellington, prime rib, ham or duck on the table this year? The whole Christmas menu, dish by dish.
Christmas Dinner Wine PairingHow should you serve red wine with steak?
Serve Pinot Noir at 55 to 60°F and fuller reds such as Cabernet at 60 to 65°F, slightly below room temperature. That usually means 15 to 20 minutes in the refrigerator. Decant a young Pinot Noir for 20 to 30 minutes, and open the bottle while the steak rests so both are ready together.
- Cool the bottle. Put a Pinot Noir in the refrigerator 15 to 20 minutes before dinner; a Cabernet needs about 10. A warm kitchen makes red wine taste alcoholic and flat.
- Chill the white properly. Serve Chardonnay at 50 to 55°F: out of the refrigerator about 15 minutes before pouring, so it isn't too cold to taste.
- Open while the steak rests. A filet rests 5 to 10 minutes after cooking. Open and decant the wine then, so it has time to breathe.
- Decant to match the wine. Twenty to 30 minutes is enough for a young Pinot Noir. A structured or cellar-worthy bottle, such as the Heritage Block, can take up to an hour.
- Use a wide glass. A wide-bowled Burgundy glass gathers Pinot Noir's aromas; a taller Bordeaux glass suits Cabernet. Pour about 5 ounces, so a bottle serves five glasses.
The guide on whether Pinot Noir should be chilled has serving temperatures by style.
What should you pour for a Christmas Eve, New Year's or anniversary filet dinner?
For a filet dinner for two, one bottle of Pinot Noir is about two and a half glasses each. For Christmas Eve or a New Year's dinner for six to eight, plan on half a bottle per adult and open a Rosé or Chardonnay to start. A magnum suits a whole tenderloin or chateaubriand on a bigger table.
| Occasion | What changes | What to pour |
|---|---|---|
| Anniversary or Valentine's for two | A small table, a special bottle | One Pinot Noir, such as the 2021 Heritage Block |
| Christmas Eve | Often filet instead of a large roast, with seafood earlier | Chardonnay with the first course, Pinot Noir with the filet |
| New Year's Eve | Surf and turf, a long evening | Rosé to start, Chardonnay and Pinot Noir both open |
| Dinner party for six to eight | Whole roasted tenderloin or chateaubriand | A Pinot Noir magnum plus a Chardonnay |
For a filet dinner we put the whole evening in one box: The Dinner Table holds the 2025 Shoshana Rosé to open, the 2021 Ritchie Vineyard Chardonnay (one of Robb Report's Top 50 California Chardonnays of the Century) for the first course, and the 2022 Red Barn Block Pinot Noir for the main, steak or roast. It is $199 with $25 flat-rate shipping. Shipped wine takes about two to five business days and an adult 21 or older must sign at delivery, so order a week or two ahead; carriers are busy the week of the holiday. We ship through Vinoshipper to most U.S. states, not all, and the checkout confirms the address before you pay.
Rosé to open, the Ritchie Chardonnay for the first course, Red Barn Block Pinot Noir with the filet: The Dinner Table, in one box.
Shop The Dinner TableFrequently asked questions
- What wine goes best with filet mignon?
- A medium-bodied red with soft tannin, above all Pinot Noir; Merlot and older Cabernet also work. Domaine de la Rivière, a Russian River Valley family estate, pours its 2022 Red Barn Block Pinot Noir (96 points, The Tasting Panel; Double Gold, San Francisco Chronicle) and 2022 Two Forces Pinot Noir (98 points, The Tasting Panel; Double Gold, San Francisco Chronicle International Wine Competition) with filet.
- Is Pinot Noir good with filet mignon?
- Yes, it is one of the best matches. Filet is lean and tender, and Pinot Noir's soft tannin, fresh acidity and earthy notes suit it without overpowering it. Choose a structured, savory Pinot rather than a very light one so it stands up to the seared crust.
- Is Cabernet or Pinot Noir better with filet mignon?
- For a plain filet, Pinot Noir is usually the better match, because a young Cabernet's tannin needs fat to soften it and filet has little. With a red wine reduction, peppercorn or blue cheese sauce, or with an older Cabernet, Cabernet works well. For ribeye, Cabernet is the stronger choice.
- What wine goes with filet mignon with béarnaise sauce?
- A full-bodied Chardonnay with moderate oak, or a bright Pinot Noir. Béarnaise is butter, egg yolk and tarragon, and it needs acidity more than tannin. A dense, old-vine Chardonnay is the closest match.
- What wine goes with bacon-wrapped filet?
- A fuller Pinot Noir with dark fruit and spice, or a dry Rosé. Bacon adds smoke, salt and fat, which a Pinot with some concentration handles well. Domaine de la Rivière's 2022 Two Forces Pinot Noir has the baking spice for it.
- Can you serve white wine with steak?
- Yes, especially with lean cuts like filet mignon or with butter-based sauces. Choose a full-bodied Chardonnay with real acidity. For fatty, heavily charred cuts like ribeye, a red is the easier match.
- Should red wine be chilled for steak dinner?
- Slightly. Serve Pinot Noir at 55 to 60°F, about 15 to 20 minutes in the refrigerator, and Cabernet at 60 to 65°F. Red wine served at a warm room temperature tastes alcoholic and flat.
- What wine goes with surf and turf?
- A full-bodied Chardonnay is the safest single bottle, since it suits both lobster with drawn butter and a lean filet. Pinot Noir works with shrimp or scallops, and a dry Rosé of Pinot Noir suits both. Avoid tannic reds, which make shellfish taste metallic.
References